Logo Selective Insurance Group

Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) stock: analyst price target and their real reliability

Live quote · data updated Aug 28, 2026
Selective Insurance Group · Financials · ref. ETF XLF · 50 calls · price $92.3
💬JPI AI AssistantTry it →
What the company does: Selective Insurance Group, Inc., together with its subsidiaries, provides insurance products and services in the United States.

📈 Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) stock price

$92.3+18.1% over range
Aug 28, 25low $73.72 · high $100.15Aug 27, 26
📏 Click 2 points (left → right) to measure the change · click again to clear.
SellBuy
Hold
33% recommend buying · 6 analysts
📊 JPI status : Selective Insurance Group has never appeared in a JPI ranking (Fair or Risk +) — our methods haven't picked it to date. See the selected stocks →

🎯 SIGI price target & analyst consensusprice $92.30

The price target · all analysts combined (6 targets)
Highest target · 1 firm of 6$115+24.6%
Median target · of 6 targets$102.5+11.1%
Lowest target · 1 firm of 6$80-13.3%
Current price$92.3
Where these 6 targets sit · versus the current price · 1 target per firm, last 6 months
Above the price 583% $97 ↔ $115
Below 117% $80
⭐ What the most reliable analysts say · those who beat their sector, targets replayed on real prices

⭐ The most reliable of them, either direction: RBC Capital77% of its targets hit on this sector (172 calls tested). It aims for $115 (+25 %), call made on July 28, 2026, maturing on July 28, 2027 (31 d ago).

The 3 reliable analysts $103+12 %
The 3 other firms $97+5.1 %
How to read it: the 3 reliable firms are not filtered by optimism — 3 aim above the price, 0 below, hence their $103 median. “The 3 others” are the firms that don't pass our reliability filter on this sector.
The consensus · 6 ratings (last 6 months)
Strong Buy00%
Buy233%
Hold350%
Sell117%
Strong Sell00%
Go deeper on the analysts
All analysts (the consensus)  ·  vs  ·  the best (those who've been right)
💬 A question about Selective Insurance Group? The JPI assistant answers using our backtest data.

💰 Selective Insurance Group dividend: yield, history & growth › open the full page

1.70%annual yield
📈 Steady dividend12 yrs of consecutive dividend increases
That's ~$1.67 per share per year.

📈 Selective Insurance Group fundamentals: valuation, margins & growth › open the full page

P/E 11.5Net margin 9.1 %Revenue growth +4.5 %Cheap for the growth

Revenue, net income and margin per year

Revenue Net income · hover a bar for details
2022
marg. 6 %
2023
Rev +19%Profit +65%
2024
Rev +15%Profit −44%
2025
Rev +10%Profit +131%

🔎 Detailed analyses

✅ Historical analyst reliability on SIGI

Hit rate measured on targets already matured (12 months), replayed against real prices. Click a header to sort.

Firm % right i Gain vs sector i Calls i
JMP Securities 100% +28.7% 2
RBC Capital  100% +28.3% 2
B of A Securities  100% +13.0% 6
Keefe, Bruyette & Woods  75% +7.3% 4
Morgan Stanley  67% +0.5% 3
Credit Suisse 50% +16.8% 4
BMO Capital  50% +1.4% 4
Oppenheimer  0% -12.0% 2

📊 What $1,000 invested in Selective Insurance Group would be worth › open the full page

In short — $1,000 invested in Selective Insurance Group 10 years ago would be worth $2,889 today, i.e. +11%/yr on average. Best year: 2016 (+32%), worst: 2024 (-18%). Price performance, excluding dividends.

If I'd invested $1,000 in Selective Insurance Group

InvestmentWorth todayGain
1 years ago$1,127+13%
3 years ago$955-4%
5 years ago$1,430+43%
→ See Selective Insurance Group's full return history + gain calculator

Return by year (Selective Insurance Group)

YearReturn$1,000 invested at year start
2026 (YTD)+15%$1,154 (+15%)
2025-2%$1,127 (+13%)
2024-18%$929 (-7%)
→ See Selective Insurance Group's full return history + gain calculator
⚠️ Past performance, not predictive nor advice. Prices in $, excluding dividends. Yahoo Finance data.

📰 Recent news on Selective Insurance Group

Loading news…

📋 All analyst calls on SIGI

■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$102
Price at call : $94.66 — gap to target +8%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +11%
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (2 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 46.6% · -0.7% (279 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 30, 27
BMO Capital 
Jul 28, 26
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$97
Price at call : $94.4 — gap to target +3%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +5%
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (4 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 20.4% · -12.2% (54 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 28, 27
RBC Capital 
Jul 27, 26
▲ Outperform · 🎯$115
Price at call : $94.4 — upside +22%
Today : $92.3 — upside +25%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 54.7% · +4.6% (172 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 27, 27
Piper Sandler 
Jul 15, 26
■ Neutral neutral · not a buy · 🎯$103
Price at call : $93.65 — gap to target +10%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +12%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 42.6% · +1.2% (235 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 15, 27
RBC Capital 
Jul 13, 26
▲ Outperform · 🎯$110
Price at call : $96.34 — upside +14%
Today : $92.3 — upside +19%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 54.7% · +4.6% (172 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 13, 27
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$101
Price at call : $95.53 — gap to target +6%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +9%
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (2 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 46.6% · -0.7% (279 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 8, 27
▼ Underweight · 🎯$80
Price at call : $97.99 — upside -18%
Today : $92.3 — upside -13%
🎯 on SIGI : 0% (1 call matured) · 📊 on Finance : 50.1% · +1.8% (387 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 6, 27
Piper Sandler 
May 26, 26
■ Neutral neutral · not a buy · 🎯$93
Price at call : $89.4 — gap to target +4%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +1%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 42.6% · +1.2% (235 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : May 26, 27
See the other 42 calls, newest to oldest
Oppenheimer 
May 21, 26
▲ Outperform · 🎯$105
Price at call : $90.7 — upside +16%
Today : $92.3 — upside +14%
🎯 on SIGI : 0% (1 call matured) · 📊 on Finance : 37.7% · -3.6% (77 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : May 21, 27
BMO Capital 
May 7, 26
▲ Outperform · 🎯$97
Price at call : $84.69 — upside +15%
Today : $92.3 — upside +5%
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (4 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 20.4% · -12.2% (54 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : May 7, 27
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$88
Price at call : $85.22 — gap to target +3%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -5%
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (2 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 46.6% · -0.7% (279 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Apr 24, 27
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$84
Price at call : $81.4 — gap to target +3%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -9%
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (2 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 46.6% · -0.7% (279 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Apr 7, 27
RBC Capital 
Mar 23, 26
▲ Outperform · 🎯$95
Price at call : $74.58 — upside +27%
Today : $92.3 — upside +3%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 54.7% · +4.6% (172 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Mar 23, 27
Piper Sandler 
Feb 2, 26
■ Neutral neutral · not a buy · 🎯$86
Price at call : $86.82 — gap to target -1%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -7%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 42.6% · +1.2% (235 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Feb 2, 27
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$81
Price at call : $84 — gap to target -4%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -12%
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (2 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 46.6% · -0.7% (279 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jan 6, 27
Piper Sandler 
Dec 22, 25
■ Neutral neutral · not a buy · 🎯$79
Price at call : $85.62 — gap to target -8%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -14%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 42.6% · +1.2% (235 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Dec 22, 26
Morgan Stanley 
Nov 17, 25
▼ Underweight · 🎯$72
Price at call : $78.46 — upside -8%
Today : $92.3 — upside -22%
🎯 on SIGI : 0% (1 call matured) · 📊 on Finance : 50.1% · +1.8% (387 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Nov 17, 26
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$82
Price at call : $76.87 — gap to target +7%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -11%
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (2 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 46.6% · -0.7% (279 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Oct 24, 26
▼ Underweight · 🎯$73
Price at call : $84.26 — upside -13%
Today : $92.3 — upside -21%
🎯 on SIGI : 0% (1 call matured) · 📊 on Finance : 50.1% · +1.8% (387 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Oct 7, 26
BMO Capital 
Aug 5, 25
▲ Outperform · 🎯$88
Price at call : $78.01 — upside +13%
Today : $92.3 — upside -5%
Expected +13% · Actual +24% · Reason (≥ +15%) : ✓ Yes
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (4 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 20.4% · -12.2% (54 calls)
+23.9%
stock +24% · XLF +12%
matured Aug 5, 26
▼ Underweight · 🎯$72
Price at call : $78.01 — upside -8%
Today : $92.3 — upside -22%
Expected -8% · Actual +24% · Reason (≤ −15%) : ✗ No
🎯 on SIGI : 0% (1 call matured) · 📊 on Finance : 50.1% · +1.8% (387 calls)
-23.9%
stock +24% · XLF +12%
matured Aug 5, 26
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$84
Price at call : $81.02 — gap to target +4%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -9%
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (2 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 46.6% · -0.7% (279 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 28, 26
Piper Sandler 
Jul 25, 25
■ Neutral neutral · not a buy · 🎯$79
Price at call : $78.43 — gap to target +1%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -14%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 42.6% · +1.2% (235 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 25, 26
Morgan Stanley 
Jul 25, 25
■ Equal-Weight neutral · not a buy · 🎯$86
Price at call : $77.63 — gap to target +11%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -7%
🎯 on SIGI : 0% (1 call matured) · 📊 on Finance : 50.1% · +1.8% (387 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 25, 26
Morgan Stanley 
May 19, 25
■ Equal-Weight neutral · not a buy · 🎯$90
Price at call : $89.04 — gap to target +1%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -2%
🎯 on SIGI : 0% (1 call matured) · 📊 on Finance : 50.1% · +1.8% (387 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : May 19, 26
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$92
Price at call : $86.89 — gap to target +6%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -0%
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (2 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 46.6% · -0.7% (279 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Apr 30, 26
BMO Capital 
Apr 29, 25
▲ Outperform · 🎯$96
Price at call : $87.23 — upside +10%
Today : $92.3 — upside +4%
Expected +10% · Actual -4% · Reason (≥ +15%) : ✗ No
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (4 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 20.4% · -12.2% (54 calls)
-3.8%
stock -4% · XLF +7%
matured Apr 29, 26
Morgan Stanley 
Apr 10, 25
■ Equal-Weight neutral · not a buy · 🎯$85
Price at call : $86.63 — gap to target -2%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -8%
🎯 on SIGI : 0% (1 call matured) · 📊 on Finance : 50.1% · +1.8% (387 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Apr 10, 26
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$93
Price at call : $85.24 — gap to target +9%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +1%
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (2 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 46.6% · -0.7% (279 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Feb 7, 26
■ Equal-Weight neutral · not a buy · 🎯$87
Price at call : $83.49 — gap to target +4%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -6%
🎯 on SIGI : 0% (1 call matured) · 📊 on Finance : 50.1% · +1.8% (387 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Feb 3, 26
BMO Capital 
Jan 31, 25
▲ Outperform · 🎯$92
Price at call : $82.77 — upside +11%
Today : $92.3 — upside -0%
Expected +11% · Actual +2% · Reason (≥ +15%) : ✗ No
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (4 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 20.4% · -12.2% (54 calls)
+2.3%
stock +2% · XLF +5%
matured Jan 31, 26
JMP Securities
Jan 30, 25
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 unranked overall
in progress (365j)
matures : Jan 30, 26
▲ Outperform · 🎯$116
Price at call : $91.22 — upside +27%
Today : $92.3 — upside +26%
Expected +27% · Actual -9% · Reason (≥ +15%) : ✗ No
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (2 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 46.6% · -0.7% (279 calls)
-8.9%
stock -9% · XLF +16%
matured Jan 10, 26
■ Equal-Weight neutral · not a buy · 🎯$105
Price at call : $99.2 — gap to target +6%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +14%
🎯 on SIGI : 0% (1 call matured) · 📊 on Finance : 50.1% · +1.8% (387 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Dec 5, 25
BMO Capital 
Oct 30, 24
▲ Outperform · 🎯$105
Price at call : $90.82 — upside +16%
Today : $92.3 — upside +14%
Expected +16% · Actual -17% · Reason (≥ +15%) : ✗ No
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (4 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 20.4% · -12.2% (54 calls)
-17.0%
stock -17% · XLF +13%
matured Oct 30, 25
RBC Capital 
Oct 23, 24
■ Sector Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$99
Price at call : $93.57 — gap to target +6%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +7%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 54.7% · +4.6% (172 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Oct 23, 25
▼ Underperform · 🎯$102
Price at call : $95.31 — upside +7%
Today : $92.3 — upside +11%
Expected +7% · Actual -20% · Reason (≤ −15%) : ✓ Yes
🎯 on SIGI : 100% (3 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 44.4% · -3.4% (117 calls)
+19.7%
stock -20% · XLF +12%
matured Oct 22, 25
▼ Underperform · 🎯$96
Price at call : $93.94 — upside +2%
Today : $92.3 — upside +4%
Expected +2% · Actual -12% · Reason (≤ −15%) : ✗ No
🎯 on SIGI : 100% (3 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 44.4% · -3.4% (117 calls)
+12.3%
stock -12% · XLF +13%
matured Oct 10, 25
BMO Capital 
Jul 24, 24
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$95
Price at call : $87.66 — gap to target +8%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +3%
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (4 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 20.4% · -12.2% (54 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 24, 25
JMP Securities
Jul 23, 24
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 unranked overall
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 23, 25
RBC Capital 
Jul 22, 24
■ Sector Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$96
Price at call : $86.36 — gap to target +11%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +4%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 54.7% · +4.6% (172 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 22, 25
▲ Outperform · 🎯$99
Price at call : $83.49 — upside +19%
Today : $92.3 — upside +7%
Expected +19% · Actual +9% · Reason (≥ +15%) : ✗ No
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (2 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 46.6% · -0.7% (279 calls)
+8.9%
stock +9% · XLF +22%
matured Jul 22, 25
Piper Sandler 
Jul 22, 24
■ Neutral neutral · not a buy · 🎯$85
Price at call : $83.49 — gap to target +2%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target -8%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 42.6% · +1.2% (235 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jul 22, 25
▼ Underperform · 🎯$97
Price at call : $96.34 — upside +1%
Today : $92.3 — upside +5%
Expected +1% · Actual -9% · Reason (≤ −15%) : ✗ No
🎯 on SIGI : 100% (3 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 44.4% · -3.4% (117 calls)
+8.9%
stock -9% · XLF +24%
matured Jul 11, 25
RBC Capital 
Jun 24, 24
■ Sector Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$103
Price at call : $91.8 — gap to target +12%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +12%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 54.7% · +4.6% (172 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Jun 24, 25
JMP Securities
Apr 15, 24
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 unranked overall
in progress (365j)
matures : Apr 15, 25
Oppenheimer 
Apr 5, 24
▲ Outperform · 🎯$120
Price at call : $104.5 — upside +15%
Today : $92.3 — upside +30%
Expected +15% · Actual -21% · Reason (≥ +15%) : ✗ No
🎯 on SIGI : 0% (1 call matured) · 📊 on Finance : 37.7% · -3.6% (77 calls)
-21.2%
stock -21% · XLF +6%
matured Apr 5, 25
Piper Sandler 
Apr 1, 24
■ Neutral neutral · not a buy · 🎯$104
Price at call : $104.96 — gap to target -1%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +13%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 42.6% · +1.2% (235 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Apr 1, 25
■ Market Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$109
Price at call : $97.04 — gap to target +12%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +18%
🎯 on SIGI : 50% (2 calls matureds) · 📊 on Finance : 46.6% · -0.7% (279 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Feb 5, 25
RBC Capital 
Feb 2, 24
■ Sector Perform neutral · not a buy · 🎯$105
Price at call : $99.15 — gap to target +6%
Today : $92.3 — gap to target +14%
🎯 on SIGI : no call matured yet · 📊 on Finance : 54.7% · +4.6% (172 calls)
in progress (365j)
matures : Feb 1, 25

Frequently asked questions

Should I buy Selective Insurance Group stock?

This isn't buy advice. For Selective Insurance Group, the analyst consensus is "Hold", with an average price target of $103 (+11% vs the current price). What matters is their past reliability on this stock: the most reliable one is right 100% of the time (2 calls tracked on Selective Insurance Group). We show the numbers — you decide.

Is it too late to buy Selective Insurance Group? How high can it go?

The most bullish analyst target on Selective Insurance Group is $115 (+25% above today's price); the average is $103. That's the upside they see. Check how reliable those analysts have actually been on Selective Insurance Group on our site before trusting it.

Is Selective Insurance Group still a good buy?

The most useful "opinion" isn't an opinion — it's a track record: 8 analysts have a real record on Selective Insurance Group, the best hitting 100% over 2 calls. Current consensus: "Hold". Make your call on data, not noise.

Should you invest in Selective Insurance Group? The case for and against

The arguments for and against, one by one, from the numbers: why invest in SIGI (and why hesitate).

What has Selective Insurance Group's past performance been?

Historical returns and a "how much if I had invested" calculator: SIGI performance & returns.

Does Selective Insurance Group pay a dividend?

Yield, consistency and growth history of the dividend: SIGI's dividend.

Other Finance stocks

Go further

JPI AI Analyst AI assistant · JPI Invest
Answers based on the tool’s data · not financial advice · full version (free)